Managing is mostly not beneficial

Ben Steenstra
25 Mar 2019 | 4 mins read
Ben also wrote about

In 1909, the then mining engineer Frederick Winslow Taylor published "The Principles of Scientific Management". He wanted to increase efficiency within his mine and saw that there was little cooperation between the different mine employees. By simplifying work and implementing rules and structure he would improve productivity and increased income without the extra costs.

managent is mostly not beneficial

His publications were the starting signal of taking management serious and most of his management theories are - unfortunately - are being educated at most universities.

The emergence of Management

There are a few factors that make a thorough determination to investigate whether management is still desirable.

  1. Taylor had to deal with unskilled and unmotivated employees who worked when they had to and not because they wanted to.
  2. Taylor came from the era of the 2nd industrial revolution where everything literally and figuratively revolved around mechanics. A person was a resource. A replaceable cog in the whole.
  3. Taylor was not bothered by any knowledge of human nature and motivation. His education level as engineers equals a current 15-year-old school leaver.

When Taylor walked into the mine he saw a uncontrolled mess where everyone did something. As if all the cogs in the clock (the resources) were running at their own pace and in their own direction still expecting that the clock keeps running.

Management comes from the French word "Manage"

Taylor got his inspiration for the word management from the word 'Manage'. This literally means "taking by the hand" and "control". Horses become tame by putting a rope around their neck and let them run in circles until all motivation and free will is gone and they do exactly what you want them to do! The ideal solution for the miners and mining industry according to Taylor.

If you don't tell an employee exactly what he or she should do, it will be a mess.

There are still people who believe that employees are not naturally motivated to do the job. We are now more than 100 years later and hundreds of studies prove differently, but they stick to their lessons learned about management. These people often put a rope around their employers neck, let them run in circles until all free will and motivation is gone and than complain that their employees don’t take enough initiative.

How we can get the best out of motivated people

In 2010, Daniel Pink published the book Drive. Basis of many studies, he concludes that employees are by nature self-motivating individuals, but that an organizational change must take place beforehand. Most companies endorse management, but whatever management style you choose, management is about control. That is why Daniel Pink is talking about self-motivation. His principle is simple and consists of three pillars.

Self-Motivation comes by nature when people can fulfil three basic needs:

Autonomy: The intrinsic need to do something independently

Mastery: The intrinsic need to become good at something and to do something well

Purpose: The intrinsic need to make a real contribute to something

If those three needs are fulfilled, employees are self-motivating and will achieve the maximum without any kind of management needed.

Can a company be completely without management?

Some people believe that there is an alternative to management that exploits the maximum potential of employees. This alternative consists of three parts, namely:

  1. Autonomy, mastery and purpose
  2. A set of minimum game rules
  3. Elected leadership and democratic decision-making

In the book "Ik Ben Niet Alleen op de Wereld" by Wassili Zafiris and me, we explain how we transformed my advertising agency into a company completely without management.

Can any company be without management?

If pilots, astronauts, hospitals and nuclear power plant employees would work without the strict management principles of Taylor, many people probably die soon. For companies where 1 push of a button can damage an entire country, management is as far as we know now, the best way is to prevent catastrophes. For all companies that derive their right to exist from creativity, innovation and service, management is perhaps what stops them from becoming truly successful.

What about successful companies where management is the standard?

It has been proven that you can make a lot of money with organizations and employees that are controlled by managers. If earning money is, just like Taylor, your only goal and measurement of success, it is certainly worth trying to keep doing this.

If employee satisfaction, social impact, the right to exist in the longer term and to free the maximum potential of your employees are also on the agenda, then it is highly recommended to think about alternatives for any form of management.

Article rating: 4.5 (16 reviews)
Related articles
The Motivation-Hygiene Theory by Frederick Herzberg is a motivation theory from 1959.
30 Dec 2012
2 mins read
Is leadership necessary?
26 Mar 2019
3 mins read
Effective brainstorming- When it comes to creative brainstorming sessions or meetings for strategic decisions, it can happen that the person who shouts the loudest decides what the outcome will be.
25 Mar 2019
4 mins read
Ben Tiggelaar (1969) is a Dutch management guru.
30 Dec 2012
2 mins read
Motivation and Leadership gurus can be found here.
23 Dec 2012
1 min read
Popular articles
25 Mar 2019
4 mins read
25 Mar 2019
5 mins read
25 Mar 2019
6 mins read
25 Mar 2019
6 mins read
27 Mar 2019
3 mins read
25 Mar 2019
4 mins read
25 Mar 2019
5 mins read
25 Mar 2019
4 mins read
25 Mar 2019
4 mins read
25 Mar 2019
3 mins read

Direct contact with professionals who know alternatives for management

Business coaching

certified TheONE expert badge
leadershipteam buildingmeaningful profitmissievisiemissionvisionstrategystrategienew businessentrepreneurshipcommunicationleiderschapondernemerschappublic relation
Ben is available now
teamworkleadershipcoachingcoachdevelopmenttalent developmentreorganisation planrestructure planbeing your own bosseffectivenessidea developmentkpiperformanceinprovementleadership developmentimprovement
Kali is available now
leadershipteam buildingteamworkleadershipentrepreneurshipgmailcoachingoperationsemaildevelopmentplanninggooglewordshopify #ecommercepassive income
Hannah is available now
certified Wassili expert badge
leadershipteam buildingteam coachingentrepreneurshipondernemerschaptrainingbusiness coachingexecutivecoachingnlpneuro-semanticsbusiness developmentmanagementburn outcoachinglife coaching
Wassili will be available in 1 days 20 hours 45 mins
leadershipteam buildingentrepreneurshipretailoperationsreengineeringappleretailiossportwatchessporthorlogesfitbitrosmalen's-hertogenboschmergozzo
Marco is available now
team buildingstrategydevelopmentrecordingmusic producertrumpetproductionartist brandingfoodmusic industrymanagement frameworksenglishmusic
Jim is available
but not online right now
leadershipteam buildingteamworkleadershipbusinessstartupsfocusbalancelife styleeffectivenessefficiencyproductivitya good personal conversationcommunicationpresentation skills
Kalpesh is offline
and will be available in 16 hours 45 mins
team coachingstrategyfilm productionfilmeisseishighgatehampsteadmuswell hillswiss cottagebelsize parkwestminstercamdenhampstead heathapple mac
Robin is offline
and will be available in 17 hours 45 mins
team buildingstartupsteprtechnical designprogram manager icttelinuxdatahaarlemhaarlkennermerland
Stijn will be available in 1 days 13 hours 45 mins
team buildingictfinancialmarketing and communicationproductivityfinancial itappleiosandroidwindows 10marketingbusiness developmentsalescrminterim management
Rens will be available in 1 days 13 hours 45 mins
leadershipstrategypeoplebusiness modelmarketingprbrand managementcontent marketingbrandingemail marketingcampaign managementviralssocial media marketingconversion optimizationhr
Karel will be available in 1 days 13 hours 45 mins
leadershipentrepreneurshipbusiness planstartupsamsterdamrotterdamphotographypaintingpositiveminddevelopmentmindsetmarketingmanagementstartenglish
Viktória is offline
and will be available in 1 days 13 hours 45 mins
leadershipinnovationbusinessmodelscopenhagencareeradvisecareerpersonal developmentbusiness developmentenglishdanishbulgarian
Kristina will be available in 1 days 13 hours 45 mins
team coachinggroup dynamicsspiritual coachingspiritual healingmeditationtransformationmiracle healingpractitioner
Wim will be available in 1 days 13 hours 45 mins
Michael will be available in 1 days 14 hours 45 mins
leadershipaccountmanagementplanningfinancialmarketing and communicationproblem solverberlincomputer hardwarecomputer setupcomputer gamesasian foodbakingmexicaneuropejapanese food
Mason is offline
and will be available in 1 days 14 hours 46 mins
meaningful profitmediaconceptsjournalismsocial impactpublishingcontent strategyconcept developmenttraveljournalisminspirational talkspublishingboeken schrijvenboeken uitgevencommunicatie
Aranka will be available in 1 days 16 hours 15 mins
leadershipleadershiporganizationgoal settingmarketingsalesseosefitnessbaseballhockeylacrossevolleyballweightliftingenglish
Gavin will be available in 1 days 19 hours 45 mins
team buildingpassive incomemarketing and communicationcommunicationmarketingcontent marketing
Dionyos is offline
and will be available in 1 days 20 hours 45 mins
leadershipstrategyentrepreneurshipbusinessemailstartupsinnovationorganizationself confidencementalitywinninglettersstructureamsterdambucharest
Sam is available now
Incoming call
block this user
Instant call from
Hang on...
no answer
They're busy
€ 0,00 PM
Will you accept
the charges for this call?
I'm the ONE
Sorry, I can't answer now, please call me in 5 minutes
Sorry, I can't answer now, please call me in 5 minutes
Callback request
More info on "callback request" Less info on "callback request"