Iron Maiden Get Sued, Forced To Change Setlist Over Accusations Of Plagiarism

certified Strife expert badge
3 mins read
Glenn also wrote about

iron-maiden-get-sued-forced-to-change-setlist-over-accusations-of-plagiarism

Iron Maiden are currently touring the world supporting their latest album "The Book Of Souls". Yet this time, the band is forced to keep two songs off their setlist as they are being sued for an alleged copyright breach.

The songs in question are "Hallowed Be Thy Name" from 1982's "The Number Of The Beast" as well as "The Nomad" from their release "Brave New World" back in 2000. Apparently lyrical and musical elements of Beckett's "Life's Shadow" are used as part of the tracks. While Iron Maiden bassist and founding member Steve Harris made an agreement with Bob Barton, who recorded "Life's Shadow", he did not give credits to or even acknowledge the original songwriter Brian Quinn. Therefore Quinn is now suing Harris as well as guitarist Dave Murray.

Barry McKay, who is representing Brian Quinn in this legal dispute, recently explained to Metal Talk: 'I can’t understand why he [Steve Harris] did not credit Brian back in 1982 as a co-writer as he was clearly listed as a writer of ‘Life’s Shadow’ on the Beckett LP. As music publisher for my old friend Brian Quinn, not only of ‘Life’s Shadow’ but of all of his other songs, I am, through the Chancery Division of the High Court, having to seek a co-writer’s credit from Steve Harris and his publishers for Brian, as well as damages. I always do my best to avoid going to court and I did try.'

Apparently the goal is to come to a licensing agreement through negotiation, preferably before 2018, which would mean that "Hallowed Be Thy Name" could make a return to the band's setlist for good.

The publicist of Iron Maiden, Alan Edwards, has also released the following statement about the situation: 

'Iron Maiden management are aware of the claim made against Steve Harris and Dave Murray, by Barry McKay and Brian Quinn. The dispute concerns the song ‘Life’s Shadow’, a song originally written in the early 1970s, credited to Robert Barton and Brian Ingham, and recorded by the band Beckett. Steve Harris was a fan of Beckett and some lines from ‘Life’s Shadow’ were referenced in Steve’s song ‘Hallowed Be Thy Name’, which was recorded by Iron Maiden and appeared on the album ‘The Number Of The Beast’ which was released in 1982.

As far as Steve is concerned, this matter was settled some years ago by agreement with Robert Barton, but it turns out there is a dispute between the two original writers as to their respective shares in ‘Life’s Shadow’. Mr Barton maintains he was the writer of the lyrics of ‘Life’s Shadow’ and said: ‘I wrote the lyrics of ‘Life’s Shadow’ and am happy with how Iron Maiden have, and are, dealing with this matter’. Iron Maiden management will consider carefully any evidence presented by Mr. Quinn and Mr. McKay.'
(0 reviews)
Share this article

Related articles

Show more

THE ONES WHO LOVE MUSIC

Music
online
Eva van Kuik
Eva van Kuik
$ 0.38 PM
show profile
Amstelveen ,  Netherlands
Languages: English, Dutch
concert music photography concert photography music photographer music journalism concert reviews music industry concerts songs albums concert photographer album review music updates music strife
Eva is available now
Call anyway
Ruben Hultman
Ruben Hultman
$ 0.06 PM
I'm the ONE Songwriter & Musician, active since 2009. Solo-Artist since 2015.
show profile
Örebro Municipality ,  Sweden
Languages: English, Swedish
guitar drums piano vocals vocallessons bass song writing music strife music studio songs recording bands swedish
Ruben will be available in 6 hours 15 mins
Call anyway
Rasmus Jersborg
Rasmus Jersborg
$ 0.38 PM
show profile
tech support, music magazine
København ,  Denmark
Languages: Danish, English, Swedish
concert music strife article writing music photographer music journalism editing festival reviews concert reviews music industry music strife windows programming linux
Rasmus will be available in 15 hours 15 mins
Call anyway
Harrie van der Lubbe
Harrie van der Lubbe
Free
(16)
I'm the ONE that might be able to help you If you have difficult technical questions
show profile
Creative Developer
Tangerang ,  Indonesia
Languages: German, English, Indonesian, Dutch, Thai
singing classical choir video calls messaging agents p2p platform jakarta karawaci cmas dutch english bitterballen homebrewing stoofvlees
Harrie is offline
and available now
Callback request
Dave Fric
Dave Fric
$ 0.95 PM
I'm the ONE who studied, travelled, made business and met plenty smart people with knowledge
show profile
Work on computer
Badung Regency ,  Indonesia
Languages: Czech, English
techno shopping food nature bali sport watersports sports surfing language culture party view rentals waterfalls
Dave will be available in 15 mins
Call anyway