Album Review: Nothing But Thieves- Broken Machine

certified Strife expert badge
6 mins read



I have a running inside joke with my friends. That joke is that is whenever they ask me if I’ve heard of band X or band Y, I will always respond with: “I haven’t listened to them but you can always assume that I know of them.” And it’s the same for Nothing But Thieves. They’ve slowly but surely been gaining steam, mostly through social media. So, let’s have a look at their sophomore album ‘Broken Machine’.

The album opens up with ‘I Was Just A Kid’. The song starts off with insistent heavy drums. It sounds reminiscent of Frank Carter & The Rattlesnakes. The song explores the loss of one’s childhood innocence, and the idea of wanting something to believe in. In terms of production value, the vocals on this opening track sound a little distorted, but if anything, it works to the songs advantage—with the repetitive drum in the background building in intensity and helping to better convey the songs message. During the verses, the instrumentals sound muted, or until the chorus hits where the plucky bass takes the lead.
Throughout this first track you can hear all sorts of musical influences flow through this song, and each verse seems to explore a different kind of genre, but unfortunately, I’m not sure if it works. In terms of the lyricism, there’s nothing that really jumps out at you from a first listen. But the thing that makes this band shine (if not the song writing), it’s the instrumentals as it propels it from okay to something catchy.

Following on from that is ‘Amsterdam’. The song starts off with almost like a mystical sound, and it reminds you of something that you might hear if you were at a funfair, from a first listen it becomes obvious that it’ll be the polar opposite to ‘I was just a kid’. The pace of this song is a hundred times faster than the song that precedes it, and it’s honestly a little jarring. When I was listening to this album, I couldn’t quite put my finger on who this band reminded me of, but to me, they’re reminiscent of Florence and the Machine mixed with Arctic Monkeys. The next track is ‘Sorry’. It starts off with a slow, mellow bass. When I first sat down to listen to this album, I went into it with an open mind and I’m sorry to say that it left me feeling a little…underwhelmed. The lyricism here balances dangerously close to being cliched. Though the song itself carries an interesting story about a relationship gone sour, it sounds vague enough that we, as the listener don’t really get the chance to emotionally connect to the lyrics. From the entirety of the album, this for me, was a song that felt a little weak when compared to the songs that follow it. Even the instrumentals which are a joy to listen to, don’t seem to have as much force to them and as such make the song feel a little samey.

‘Live Like Animals’ offers a sound that is like nothing else on the album. From here onwards, the musical genre of the record goes from definite alt-rock sound to peppy electronic pop. The first verse here opens up with rapping, and though it works well, it’s so unexpected and a bit of a strange addition, when this is the only song on the record that features it. A song all about getting used to modern day life, and having no choice but putting up with people’s attitudes and priorities.

​‘Soda’ is without a doubt the strongest and most confident song on the entire record and my personal favourite. It has a definite retro inspired sound, and it reminds you of the stereotypes you’d imagine about 1950’s America. It’s a wholly unapologetically confident song, exploring the vocalist’s own personal demons and how overwhelming it can be to deal with them (‘Maybe when I was a kid/ I was dropped on my head’.) The lyrics here and witty and sardonic, and feel like a bit of fresh air when it’s compared to the rest of the album.

One of my biggest problems with this album was the themes, as the latter half of the record all but ignores the previous themes of societal issues and prejudices and focuses exclusively on the battle of their own demons and relationships. The musical genres seemed a little confusing as well, as it swings wildly between alt-rock and indie to pop but when the two genres get blended together, the results feel a little clunky.

Overall, I’m really sorry to say that even though thematically the idea of the album appealed to me (especially on ‘Hell, Yeah’), the rest of this record just wasn’t my cup of tea. The best word I have for this album is underwhelming. Perhaps if all the songs were similar to Soda in terms of execution, theme, instrumentals and lyricism—it could have been a pretty solid addition to the great albums we’ve already had this year, but to me, it fell a little short of that expectation. Broken Machine felt like a jumble of ideas and themes, but none of them truly felt explored thoroughly or flowed like a progressive story line. An adequate record, and one that with perhaps a little refining and emphasis on themes could shine like a diamond.

​Written by Asya Kardzhaliyska 

(0 reviews)
Share this article

Related articles

Show more

Popular articles

Show more


Musicians & singers
Abigail Milmon
Abigail Milmon
$ 0.08 PM
I'm the ONE who goes to every concert I can.
show profile
Washington County ,  United States
Languages: English
'Strife' badge for Abigail Milmon
concert photography concert reviews concerts concert photographer quality concepts for music videos concepts for artist artwork singer photography concert artist management writing social media music test
Abigail will be available in 8 hours 4 mins
Call anyway
Natalie R
Natalie R
$ 0.08 PM
I'm the ONE who is always there to share an enthusiasm for music and living in the moment.
show profile
Music-based Writer
Monroe County ,  United States
Languages: English
'Strife' badge for Natalie R
guitar basics music reviews music strife photography design writing artist graphic design musicjournalism art photo editing journalist
Natalie is available now
Call me
Sarah  Smiles
Sarah Smiles
$ 0.08 PM
I'm the ONE who's passionate about music, writing, and dance.
show profile
Student and Writer
Duval County ,  United States
Languages: English, Korean
'Strife' badge for Sarah  Smiles
music concert reviews concerts music reviews lyric interpretations writing music strife concert reviews concerts bands lyrics album review themes articles
Sarah will be available in 20 hours 34 mins
Call anyway
Harrie van der Lubbe
Harrie van der Lubbe
I'm the ONE that might be able to help you If you have difficult technical questions
show profile
Creative Developer
Tangerang ,  Indonesia
Languages: German, English, Indonesian, Dutch, Thai
'TheONE' badge for Harrie van der Lubbe
singing classical choir video calls messaging agents p2p platform jakarta karawaci cmas dutch english bitterballen homebrewing stoofvlees
Harrie is available now
Call anyway
Burns Oz
Burns Oz
$ 0.06 PM
I'm the ONE who thinks outside the box! get expert advice !
show profile
Music producer
Melbourne City ,  Australia
Languages: English, Turkish
daw electronic music production english turkish car mechanical hacks
Burns is available
but not online right now
Callback request